On 9 October 2026, Justice P.B. Balaji of the Madras High Court set aside a Trade Marks Registry order refusing Hyderabad-based Tregum Remedies Private Limited's application for the composite mark 'THE SKIN COMPANY', directing the Registry to advertise the mark in the Trade Marks Journal under Section 20(1) read with Rule 39.
The Court flagged serious procedural and substantive errors in the Registry's refusal order: the examination report had raised an objection under Section 9(1)(b) (descriptiveness), yet the final refusal relied on Section 9(1)(a) (lack of distinctiveness) without addressing the applicant's written reply. The Registry had also conflated 'identical' and 'deceptively similar' under Section 11 and treated similar formative marks inconsistently across applicants.
Reiterating the anti-dissection rule, the Court held that a composite mark must be evaluated as a whole rather than broken into generic words—and noted that advertising an application merely opens it to third-party opposition rather than conferring an unfair monopoly.
When Registry examination or hearing orders ignore written replies or dissect composite brand names unfairly, Section 91 appeals before the High Court IP Division offer effective relief. Shadow Business Solutions supports trademark objection replies and hearing coordination.
Talk to our team about your business requirements.